New Super Lugio U receives mixed reviews, with some players enjoying the new levels and gameplay, especially for newcomers. However, others criticize the 100 second time limit, repetitive gameplay, and lack of original Mario games.

This game is praised for its challenging and fun gameplay, featuring a distinct Super Mario Bros. experience and multiple characters. It offers a unique experience with local co-op, reminiscent of Super Mario Bros.. However, some levels can be frustrating and the Co-op mode may lose its positive feedback.